Approaches to the study of Colonialism & Nationalism in India - Political Science

Approaches to the study of Colonialism & Nationalism in India



History is a very interesting subject.The study of any historical occurrence is filled with debates and contradictions.It is viewed from various different perspectives and makes a wide variety of opposing assumptions.(Going into the past,at the moment,isn't possible to verify :p)
It is even more fascinating in India's case,the study Colonialism and Nationalism in India has been done from four major different perspectives:
  1. Imperialist Approach
  2. Marxist Approach
  3. Nationalist Approach
  4. Subaltern Approach
It will be very interesting and amusing to note what the views of the above mentioned approaches are.In this post i will discuss the imperialistic approach

The Imperialist Approach
The Imperialist approach is also known as the Cambridge school and this perspective is seen in the writings of viceroys such as Lord Duferin, Curzon and Minto.Its views on Colonialism and Nationalism in India can be summed up in the following points :
  1. India under British rule grew into a stage at which she could advance claim to the sight of self-government.
  2. The British rule was essentially Benevolent,understood the aspirations of Indians and gradually moved towards it fulfillment.
  3. The imperialistic historiographers deny the existence of colonial exploitation,underdevelopment and other anti-imperialistic and nationalistic forces.
  4. They also deny the existence of colonialism as an economic,political and social structure.
  5. They say it was simply a foreign rule and neither was it exploitative.Hence,they do not agree with the view that the socio-economic and political development of India required the overthrow of colonialism.
  6. They do not see any basic contradiction between the British and Indian interests which led to the national movement.
  7. India as a nation was a myth.India was neither a nation nor a nation-in-making but a group of different castes and religious groups which are the real basis of political organisation.
  8. Nationalism in India was not anti-imperialistic;rather the politicization of Indian society developed along the lines of traditional social formations such as linguistic,regional,castes or religious communities rather modern categories of class and nation.
  9. The struggle against colonialism was a motiveless and simulated combat.It was merely a product of the need and interests of the elite groups who used to serve either their own narrow interests or the interests of their perspective groups.
  10. The basic pattern was of an educated middle class reared by British rule engaged in various renaissance activities and virtually turning against their masters and so giving birth to modern nationalism out of frustrated, selfish ambitions, ideals of patriotism and democracy derived from western culture or natural revulsion against foreign rule.
  11. The imperialist approach questioned the ontology of a unified nationalist movement and has traced instead only a series of localized movements in colonial India.
  12. India was not a nation but an aggregate of desperate interest groups and they were united as they had to operate within a centralized national administrative framework created by the British.
Criticism and analysis of the imperialistic approach
  1. This approach denies the existence and legitimacy of exploitative nature of British rule and of Nationalism as a movement of the Indian people to overthrow imperialism.
  2. Categories such as nation,class,mobilization,ideology etc which are generally used by historians to analyse colonialism and nationalism are missing from this approach.
  3. It deliberately misses the economic exploitation,under development,racialism and the role of the masses in the anti-imperialistic struggle.




For complete organized notes before your exams, you can refer to this copy of Indian Polity: https://amzn.to/2QoAuWt



Want to become a leader and develop your skillset? Here is an opportunity to join the Student Leadership Program by Eat My News. Click here to know more: http://bit.ly/boardofyoungleaders

Post a Comment

15 Comments

  1. Have you ate all other approaches?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Replies
    1. Yaa I'm also searching for that.
      If you got please help me.
      My Contact=.adarshnxb.in@gmail.com

      Delete
  3. Very good But 3 other approaches??

    ReplyDelete
  4. Where are the other 3 ?
    Please help me to find !😶

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey what approaches you need?? I'll give you tell what you need??

      Delete
  5. Sir I need notes on other 3 approaches namely Marxist approach, nationalist approach, subaltern approach

    ReplyDelete
  6. Are you in need of finance? we give out guarantee cash at 3% interest rate. Contact us on any kind of finance now: financialserviceoffer876@gmail.com whatsapp Number +918929509036 Dr James Eric Finance Pvt Ltd

    ReplyDelete
  7. I need marxist and nationalist

    ReplyDelete
  8. Where can I get other approaches

    ReplyDelete
  9. Do you Need Instant Loan from $2,000 to $50,000,000.00 with no collateral required and receive a no obligation loan approval.We welcome the opportunity to show you how effective we are at helping our clients obtain the money they need to succeed. Our professional staff is available for a Free Consultation.At Patiala legitimate company Pvt , contact us now 2% interest rate, both long and short term cash reply to us (Whats App) number: +919394133968 patialalegitimate515@gmail.com 
    Mr Jeffery

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hello everyone, I’m so happy with this super team, they came to my rescue, I had payment irregularities on my report, being a single mother of 2 after I lost my job working with the Occupational Health and Safety Administration last two years here in Washington D C, to cater for the kids became another burden on me, 5 months ago my son was diagnosed of hepatitis B I couldn’t apply for a medical loan because I had a 516 poor score, I really needed help to fix my credit score, not until my ex husband’s family doctor disclosed this TEAM 760PLUS to me who helped me clear all irregularities and added a positive trade line on my report, my FICO score raised to 802 excellent score, all thanks to 760PLUS CREDIT SCORE for saving my son, if you ask me I’ll say they are reliable and the best team to work with, write them via: 760pluscreditscore at gmail dot com / 307 774 5902 cheers !

    ReplyDelete
  11. Am short of words for the amazing profit you helped me earn in just a week with binary options strategy am so sorry I doubted at the beginning, I invested $200 and earn $2,500 in just one week, and kept on investing more, today I am financially successful, you can contact him via Email: (tdameritrade077@gmail.com) whatsapp(+447883246472) I advice you shouldn't hesitate. He's great.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I have sought help out of desperation on web forums regarding my poor credit profile. Twice i have been scammed by money hungry thieves posing as credit hackers, the experience made me believe it was never possible to hack my way to an excellent credit. But i touched base with DOOM HACK via email doomhackcyberwizarduk@yahoo.com and cell I desperately needed help in increasing my credit score to be able to obtain a new place to live and pay off medical bills that was killing me from critical PTSD disability government very low income but i was ready to try again because this was a family recommendation. He (DOOM HACK) accessed the 3 credit bureaus and the FICO as well and made my dreams come through. My credit score was in the low 500 before i contacted the genius. After analyzing all credit bureaus database he stated we can achieve our aim within two weeks! I was like Wow and i was literally in tears, it has been 3 years since i last had a good credit. Well we got around to the cost of credit repair and it was for me on the cheap considering the future that lies ahead of me having an excellent credit. You can try him and i promise you will come and thank me later. +1 WHATSAPP (289)960-0524) EMAIL doomhackcyberwizarduk@yahoo.com whatsapp +1(289)960-0524)

    ReplyDelete
Emoji
(y)
:)
:(
hihi
:-)
:D
=D
:-d
;(
;-(
@-)
:P
:o
:>)
(o)
:p
(p)
:-s
(m)
8-)
:-t
:-b
b-(
:-#
=p~
x-)
(k)