Is Pakistan Happier than India?


20th March is celebrated worldwide as Universal Happiness Day, but is this  truly, a happy day for India? I guess not, the World Happiness Report of 2021, placed India at the 139th position out of the total 149 countries surveyed.

It is indeed a worrisome ranking and what further exacerbates the wound, is the fact that Pakistan has been placed at the 105th position.

Is it really possible that a country like India who has been making major developmental strides all along is the 11th worse country in terms of happiness? Are we Indians really that miserable?

Another crucial question that comes to our mind is, how is the Happiness Index measured? What are the parameters taken into consideration?

The Happiness Index is gauged by the United Nations body conducting a survey using a sample space of 1000-3000 people of a country. A 6-fold criteria is undertaken to determine the score of the country.

     1.  GDP per capita

2.  2.  Health Life Expectancy

3.  3. Social Support

4.  4. Freedom of Choice

5.  5.  Generosity

6.  6. Perception of Corruption

The first two are well defined and backed by data, but what about the other four criteria?

Now, let’s understand how factors like freedom of choice and generosity are determined. The survey is conducted by agencies who put across questions and the surveyed are supposed to answer using a scale of 0-10.                               

For example: “Have you donated to a charity in the last month?” Is a way to judge the generosity and big-heartedness of the people in a country.

Another example: “Are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the freedom to choose what you want to do with your life?” Is a way to gauge freedom of choice be it choosing a career, residence or a life-partner.

But how reliable are the responses? Can’t they be biased responses or responses influenced by prejudices? Well, there’s no way to find that out, thus, these are labelled as opiniated or perception-based replies that are not backed by any solid data.

A democratic country like India, which is one of the only country’s in the world to have shown a positive surge in the GDP numbers during the third quarter of 2020, is falling behind a country like Pakistan which along with the imminence of terrorism has been unstable in many aspects since the time of its inception. This is a theory that no well-informed Indian would be ready to accept.

I cast no doubts on the methodologies undertaken to run polls but I am also of the opinion that many who formed part of the survey have resorted to far-fetched assumptions and comparisons. They may have not solely acted on their conscious but compared their contribution to contributions by super-power countries which led to them giving a lower ranking on the 0-10 scale.

One cannot also hide from the fact that India’s happiness ranking has been worsening over the period of years and it does need to pull up its socks because GDP is not the only defining factor for a nation, happiness and prosperity of its citizen should be of utmost priority too. The ranking can be improved by changing several age-old societal prevalence’s and it’s possible only when governance is in compliance with the needs and aspirations of the people. 

 

Written By - Tushna Choksey

 

 

 

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments